Valued at more than US$250 billion, the influencer sector is at the heart of the digital economy.
Subscribe to our newsletterfor the most recent science and technology news updates.
Popular haul videos, where influencers showcase and talk about a new set of items bought, andunboxings—videos in which content creators open, display, and evaluate new products—have been extensively advertising continuous flows of consumer items that can be bought with a simple click.
But what occurs to influencer culture and widespread consumer habits when numerous individuals are concerned about their financial stability?
Social media feeds are filled with content creators urging us to save money—experts advising against purchasing trendy, possibly unnecessary items, such as large amounts of Halloween decorations or high-end skincare products.
This arrives as American tariffs cause chaos in theglobal economy and youth unemploymentsoars, and indicates increasing economic instability. Consumption, the social behavior that becomes widely discussed and intensely debated during periods of economic uncertainty, is once again in the spotlight.
For the last year, social media users have labeled nearly everything and anything as “recession indicatorsTake, for instance, influencer Kate O’Brien’s popular TikTok video demonstrating how to extract the last bit of beauty product from its container to avoid waste, which is one of many similar examples.
As concerns about a recession grow, social media trends such asdeinfluencingassist us in comprehending how popular culture deals with economic recessions.
The emergence of the recessionista
Economic downturns have consistently influenced popular culture. The jobs lost during the2007-08 global financial crisisfacilitated the emergence of the modern influencer sector.Fashion bloggersbecame more popular during this period.
Media professionals who are out of work and younger artists aiming to enter the field began using web blogs—and later, emerging social media sites such as YouTube and Instagram—to share material related to fashion, beauty, and daily life.
Pop culture in the early 2000s was characterized by indulgence, as consumers invested in items such as designer “it bags.” As the recession began,shoppers were blamedfor causing the economic decline, primarily due to spending more than they could afford. To cover these expenses, consumers were accumulating morehousehold and mortgage debt, which served as contributing factors.
The “recessionistabecame a common theme in fashion blogs. Recessionistas were intelligent, primarily female shoppers who spent considerable time browsing at discount stores suchTJ Maxxto discover great discounts on stylish items.
They instructed their online audience on how to manage money wisely and steer clear of expensive designer items. Recessionistas were portrayed as efficient shoppers. Nearly 20 years later, the recessionista has made a comeback, this time asthe deinfluencer on TikTok.
Deinfluencing content goes viral
In January 2023, the concept of deinfluencing—where social media users advise their followers to buy more affordable items instead of pricier options—emerged as a trending topic on TikTok. It rapidly gained popularity, accumulating overone billion views on TikTok.
Deinfluencing posts on TikTok initially gained attention within the platform’sbeauty community. The trend has now grown to encompass additional specialized areas such as autumn seasonal shopping and Amazon Prime Days.
Like the recessionista, de-influencing captured interest during a distinct cultural period. Thecost-of-living crisisdominated the news headlines. It became challenging for people who were having trouble affording essentials, such as groceries, to watch online videos from influencers showcasing extravagant PR packages.
Mascaragate and authenticity
Besides financial stress, the quest for genuine experiences fueled the rise of deinfluencing content. Enter: Mascaragate, the TikTok controversy involving thenotorious branded TikTok video by makeup influencerMikayla Nogueira. Nogueira was advertising L’Oréal’s latest Telescopic Lift Mascara, but TikTok users observed that she had false eyelashes.
Early critical videos criticized Nogueira for ethically questionable promotion of thoughtless purchasing. In this manner,Nogueira was framedas the same excessive female consumer from the early 2000s, and the deinfluencer as the more morally conscious recessionista.
Critics, however, arguethat de-influencing is pointless because, as a movement, it continues to push users to make purchases. Whether you market a $50 foundation from a premium beauty company or a more affordable drugstore option, you’restill promoting consumption.
But that’s the core idea behind the viral phenomenon. Deinfluencing teaches social media users how to maintain the cycle of consumption by continuing to shop, but in a more effective way. It’s a movement where social media users arerebrandingtransforming consumption into a efficient, productive endeavor for today’s unstable economic climate.
What lies in store for consumer trends?
Deinfluencing definitely encourages social media users to reflect more deeply onhow they’re spendingtheir funds. And we could all benefit from a touch of that.
But de-influencing can also have the unintended consequence of making it appear that consumers are entirely responsible for dealing with financial crises. What consumption trends from the recession era, such as de-influencing, can occasionally do isshift focusfrom those in charge of economic stability within institutions to everyday consumers.
And it’s often the purchases made by female customers, such as designer handbags and beauty items, that are considered excessive or not essential.Consumer culture and the influencer industryBoth have traditionally been female-dominated areas. Gender-specific stereotypes, such as the overzealous shopper or the unscrupulous social media personality, are frequently held responsible for economic downturns, and subsequently, women like recession experts and anti-influencers are often assigned to resolve the problem.
With the economy facing challenges, influencers will keep sharing content that encourages people to rethink their spending habits. Similar to the recessionistas of the past, they are determined to show their followers how to manage their money even when the economy is affected by tariffs—regardless of whether it’s part of their role or not.
This piece is reprinted fromThe Conversationunder a Creative Commons license. Read theoriginal article.
Provided by The Conversation
This narrative was first released onMuara Digital Team.
