OREM, Utah (AP) — Less than fourteen days priorCharlie Kirk’s assassinationIn Utah, a sheriff’s office in central California carried out three days of surveillance to get ready for a speech bythe conservative firebrandin a nearby church located in a politically supportive area.
Authorities examined possible escape paths and found local activists who were against Kirk. On the day of the indoor event in Visalia, which attracted 2,000 attendees, approximately 60 law enforcement officers kept an eye on Kirk’s movements to and from the church, including using a drone to patrol the nearby rooftops, according to Tulare County Sheriff Mike Boudreaux.
The inherent nature of Charlie Kirk’s arrival demands that you pay close attention to the possible implications,” Boudreaux stated. “He is a well-known figure and personality. Not only must we ensure the safety of those attending, but also the safety of him himself.
In contrast, Kirk’s outdoor event at Utah Valley University last week took place in an open area, yet had significantly reduced security. Six campus police officers—approximately a quarter of the department—were present at the event, which attracted 3,000 attendees, according to Jeff Long, the campus police chief, who mentioned this last week. The department has not yet confirmed if they checked nearby rooftops; the suspect shot and killed Kirk.from atop a building hundreds of feet away.
As he traveled across the country promoting his conservative values on university campuses, Kirk aimed to be as near to students as possible, enabling him to engage in spontaneous chats with those passing by. The extent of his security measures differed significantly—campus police usually handled general safety, while Kirk’s personal security team concentrated on close-proximity protection.
The assassination at Utah Valley has brought even greater focus to the role that campus police departments have in safeguarding high-profile and controversial political figures who frequently visit colleges. Security experts havequestioned everythingthe number of officers sent to the choice of holding the event outdoors, where Kirk found himself in the direct path of a sniper’s shot.
The university’s safety protocol is not included in the Utah Department of Public Safety’s inquiry regarding the shooting, stated department Commissioner Beau Mason.
Utah House Speaker Mike Schultz, a member of the Republican party, stated that legislators might initiate an assessment of safety protocols at Utah Valley after the assassination.
When Kirk addressed an audience of 700 at Illinois State University in April, over a dozen campus police officers moved through the crowd, while additional officers monitored cameras focused on surrounding buildings from an operations center. That same month, University of Wyoming police deployed approximately 15 officers for an indoor event featuring Kirk.
In some instances, the setups were comparable to last week’s debate in Utah. At an outdoor event at Michigan State University, a student organizer from the campus chapter of Turning Point USA mentioned there were eight to 10 campus officers. Kirk was the founder ofTurning Point USAone of the country’s biggest political groups with branches at high schools and colleges.
Kirk’s personal security team, consisting of approximately six individuals, was at every event.
Outdoor gatherings are more difficult to protect
Security specialists informed The Associated Press that they anticipate an increase in indoor events to safeguard against comparable incidents, as outdoor gatherings significantly heighten risk. College campuses are typically open and easy to access, which makes them highly vulnerable to shootings, according to Don Aviv, the CEO of the security company Interfor International.
Without monitoring rooftop access and obstructing the shooter’s line of sight, Aviv stated, “it doesn’t matter how many armed individuals you have surrounding the speaker, you wouldn’t have been able to prevent a long-range attack.”
Kirk asked to have the conversation outdoors at Utah Valley in order to interact with students, according to spokeswoman Ellen Treanor, who spoke with the Salt Lake Tribune. During his visit to the campus in 2019, he gave a speech in a ballroom.
The effort by Kirk’s team to keep him as approachable as possible added complexity to security arrangements, according to Aaron Woodruff, police chief at Illinois State University.
“It’s challenging to safeguard someone when there are individuals surrounding him from every direction,” Woodruff stated.
Woodruff presented a security plan to Kirk’s team over the phone and later conducted an on-site inspection. Security cameras focused on adjacent buildings enabled officials to observe rooftops and the surrounding area, according to Woodruff.
The personal aspect of Kirk’s engagements resonated with his supporters, noted Alex Bitzan, president of the TPUSA chapter at Michigan State, who was involved in organizing an April gathering on a campus lawn.
Individuals are attracted to the open dialogue. They are drawn to the reality that he is spontaneous,” Bitzan stated. “When you’re out in public like that, I can’t see what would address what occurred last Wednesday.
Daniel Schoenherr, a photographer who reported on the Michigan State event for the school’s newspaper, remembered seeing police on foot and at least two or three campus police vehicles in the vicinity. Entry to the event was straightforward. Schoenherr estimated that over 1,000 people attended, with many not being students. Kirk’s personal security concentrated on the people directly around him.
“If someone attempted to throw a brick at Kirk— that wouldn’t occur. There was significant personal security nearby,” Schoenherr stated.
Experts claim that observing rooftops is essential
The attempted assassinationConcerns about the susceptibility to sniper attacks from adjacent rooftops should have been raised following President Donald Trump’s event last year in Butler, Pennsylvania, according to James Hamilton, who established the FBI’s close protection training program.
Hamilton stated that Butler mentioned it’s not difficult to obtain a rifle, climb onto a rooftop, and fire.
Private sector security must adapt according to what clients want, Hamilton noted, adding that it would have been significantly safer to host Kirk’s events inside.
A representative from Utah Valley did not reply to email inquiries regarding security preparations, the allocation of public safety officers, and whether roof areas were examined.
This is a nightmare for the police chief,” Long, who serves as the campus police chief, stated last week. “You strive to cover all your bases, but regrettably, we didn’t today, and due to that, we experienced this tragic event.
For a University of Wyoming event in April, campus police contacted Texas A&M and other institutions that Kirk had recently visited to gain insight into how they managed security, according to Campus Police Chief Josh Holland.
His subordinates examined the door locks in the building that could have provided entry to rooftop areas. Holland mentioned there were no metal screening devices, but the 1,800 guests were not permitted to carry bags into the event at the university’s arts and sciences building. In contrast, at Utah Valley, students were permitted to bring bags.
The Turning Point USA organization did not provide a statement regarding the security measures for Kirk’s events.
The group mentioned last week that Kirk had gotten “thousands” of threats but “always focused on connecting with as many young Americans as possible rather than his own security.”
__
Brook covered events in New Orleans while Lauer reported from Philadelphia. Correspondents from the Associated Press included Jim Mustian and Jake Offenhartz in New York, Hannah Schoenbaum in Salt Lake City, and Ed White in Detroit.
